Lift Heavy! But why? Understanding Strength Training during Perimenopause & Menopause
Updated: Nov 13

If you're a woman navigating perimenopause or menopause, chances are you've heard the message: Lift heavy!
It's everywhere right now. On social media, in podcasts, and throughout the fitness industry, women are being encouraged to put down the light dumbbells and start lifting heavier weights.
But why?
If you're anything like me, being told to do something isn't enough. I want to understand the science behind it. What's actually changing in our bodies during this stage of life? Why does lifting heavier weights matter? And perhaps most importantly, what does lifting heavy actually mean?
The good news is that there's some compelling research behind the recommendations. But there's also a little more nuance to the conversation than simply picking up heavier weights.
Let's break it down.
Estrogen and Muscular Strength: What's Changing?
When we talk about menopause and muscle, the conversation often focuses on losing muscle mass. But there's another important piece of the puzzle: our ability to generate force.
To understand why this matters, we need to look briefly at how our muscles actually work.
Every time we lift a weight, climb a flight of stairs, or get up from a chair, our nervous system sends signals to our muscles, telling them to contract. Inside our muscle fibres are two proteins called actin and myosin. These proteins interact, pulling against one another to create muscular force.
Here's where estrogen comes in.
Estradiol, our primary estrogen during our reproductive years, plays an important role in maintaining muscle function. Research suggests that estrogen helps regulate how effectively myosin interacts with actin, influencing the amount of force our muscles can produce. As estradiol declines during perimenopause and menopause, changes in these processes may contribute to a loss of muscular strength.
And here's the important distinction: We can lose strength without necessarily losing an equivalent amount of muscle mass.
In other words, it's not just about how much muscle we have. It's also about how effectively that muscle works.
Why Heavy Lifting Makes a Difference
As exercise physiologist Dr. Stacy Sims explains, when estrogen declines, we need to introduce an external training stimulus to help compensate for some of the functions estrogen previously supported.
While exercise can't replace estrogen, it can stimulate physiological adaptations that help maintain muscle mass, improve neuromuscular function, and preserve our ability to generate force.
This is where resistance training, particularly heavier lifting, becomes so important.
When we lift weights, our nervous system recruits groups of muscle fibres, called motor units, to produce the force needed to move the load.
The heavier the load, the greater the force required.
Lifting heavier weights challenges our nervous system to recruit and coordinate more motor units, including those responsible for producing higher levels of force.
Over time, our bodies adapt to these demands. We become better at activating our muscles, coordinating contractions, and generating force.
These are called neuromuscular adaptations, and they're a major reason why heavier resistance training is particularly effective for developing maximal strength.
But Why Does Maximal Strength Matter?
Think of maximal strength as your body's strength reserve. The stronger we are, the smaller the percentage of our available strength we need to perform a given physical task. Whether we're lifting something heavy, climbing a steep hill, or participating in our favourite sport, greater maximal strength gives us more physical capacity to draw upon.
Maximal strength also provides an important foundation for muscular power, our ability to generate force quickly, which is essential for athletic performance and many everyday movements.
As we age, maintaining that strength reserve becomes increasingly important. And because declining estrogen during menopause may contribute to reduced muscular force production, heavier resistance training provides a particularly effective way to develop and preserve that capacity.
What Does Lifting Heavy Actually Mean?
When we talk about lifting heavy, we're generally referring to lifting challenging weights for lower repetitions, typically in the range of 2–6 repetitions per set.
But heavy is relative. What's heavy for one person might be relatively light for another. The important factor is choosing a load that challenges your ability to produce force while maintaining good technique.
In strength training, we often measure intensity as a percentage of our one-repetition maximum (1RM), which is the greatest amount of weight we can lift for one repetition. For maximal strength development, we're generally working with loads around 80–90% or more of our 1RM.
But you don't need to test your maximum to train effectively.
A useful alternative is repetitions in reserve (RIR), which refers to how many additional repetitions you could complete before reaching muscular failure. For example, finishing a set of four repetitions knowing you could perform another one or two with good technique means you're working at a challenging intensity without necessarily training to failure.
Lifting heavy isn't about pushing to your absolute limit. It's about progressively challenging your strength with appropriate loads while maintaining good technique.
Build the Foundation Before Adding the Load
While lifting heavier weights offers significant benefits, it's important to recognize that heavy lifting isn't where everyone should start.
Before increasing the load, we need to establish a solid foundation of movement competency. Understanding proper movement patterns, developing good technique, and building foundational strength are essential for preparing the body to handle heavier loads safely and effectively.
Jumping straight into heavy lifting without these foundations can increase the risk of injury.
The goal is to move well first, then progressively add load.
Strength is built over time, and a thoughtful, progressive approach will set you up for long-term success.
There's Still a Place for Lighter Weights
While heavier loads are particularly effective for developing maximal strength, that doesn't mean lighter weights and higher repetitions don't have a place in our training.
Research shows that muscle growth can occur across a wide range of loads when the training stimulus is sufficient. Lighter weights can also improve strength and muscular endurance, although heavier loads generally produce greater improvements in maximal strength.
Lighter loads can be valuable when developing foundational strength, learning movement patterns, and building muscular endurance. They can also complement heavier strength training when preparing for endurance based activities.
And we don't necessarily have to choose one over the other. A well designed program can incorporate heavier, lower repetition lifts alongside lighter, higher repetition exercises.
Even for endurance athletes, developing maximal strength remains valuable. Lighter weights can complement that work, rather than replace it.
The Benefits Go Beyond Muscle
While maintaining muscular strength is incredibly important, the benefits of resistance training extend well beyond our muscles.
Bone Health: As estrogen declines, the rate of bone breakdown can exceed bone formation, accelerating the loss of bone mineral density and increasing the risk of osteoporosis. Our bones respond to mechanical stress, and progressive resistance training places forces on the skeleton that can stimulate bone adaptation, helping maintain or improve bone density.
Metabolic Health and Body Composition: Skeletal muscle plays a major role in regulating blood glucose. When our muscles contract, they stimulate glucose uptake from the bloodstream, while regular resistance training can improve insulin sensitivity. Strength training also helps preserve lean muscle mass and can support healthier body composition, including reductions in visceral fat (the fat stored deep within the abdominal cavity), which often increases during menopause.
Joint Stability and Balance: Strong muscles help support and stabilize our joints, improving our ability to control movement and manage physical demands. Resistance training, particularly when combined with exercises that challenge coordination and balance, can improve physical function and reduce fall risk as we age.
Bringing It All Together
Lifting heavy during perimenopause and menopause isn't about chasing bigger numbers in the gym. It's about maintaining and developing the strength we need to continue doing the things we love, while supporting our long-term health and physical performance.
But how we get there matters.
That's exactly why I created Be the Change, my online strength and conditioning program designed specifically for women navigating perimenopause, menopause, and beyond.
The program begins with a six week foundational phase, including the opportunity for a personalized online movement assessment, where I review your technique and provide feedback. From there, we progressively build strength through structured training phases, incorporating heavier lifting alongside mobility, core work, and cardiovascular conditioning.
The goal is to help you build strength safely, progressively, and with purpose.
If you're ready to put the science into practice, learn more about Be the Change.


Comments